Home Breaking News Analysis: Biden takes a risk pulling troops from Afghanistan

Analysis: Biden takes a risk pulling troops from Afghanistan

Analysis: Biden takes a risk pulling troops from Afghanistan

BRUSSELS — At its start, America’s war in Afghanistan was about retribution for 9/11. Then it was about shoring up a weak executive and its weak army so that Osama bin Laden’s al-Qaida may perhaps by no means again threaten the United States.

Now it’s about over. With bin Laden lengthy since dead and the United States no longer suffering another major attack, President Joe Biden is promising to halt America’s longest war and saunter on to what he believes are larger, extra consequential challenges posed by a resurgent Russia and a rising China.

Early Newspaper

Even so, by withdrawing the remaining few thousand U.S. troops in Afghanistan by the 20th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks, Biden is taking a calculated risk that extremists in Afghanistan can be countered by U.S. and partner forces in other places in the scrape — and that he acquired’t transform the president who underestimated the resilience and reach of extremists who peaceful aim to attack the United States.

CIA Director William Burns advised Congress on Wednesday the U.S. unavoidably will lose some intelligence leverage against the extremist threat, although he urged the losses would be manageable.

“The U.S. executive’s ability to acquire and act on threats will diminish. That’s simply a fact,” Burns said. “It’s far also a fact, nonetheless, that after withdrawal, at any time when that time comes, the CIA and all of our partners in the U.S. executive will retain a suite of capabilities, a few of it remaining in place, a few of them that we are going to be able to generate, that can lend a hand us to anticipate and contest any rebuilding effort.”

There had been 2,500 to three,000 U.S. troops in Afghanistan when Biden took administrative center, the smallest number since early in the war. The number peaked at 100,000 at some point of President Barack Obama’s first term. As U.S. war casualties have declined, so has the American public’s attention. The war was barely talked about at some point of last year’s presidential contest, and pulling the budge may label politically popular.

Yet worries remain. Stephen Biddle, a Columbia College professor who has advised U.S. commanders in Afghanistan, says it’s imaginable al-Qaida may perhaps re-establish its base structure in Afghanistan once the Americans and their coalition partners leave. The Taliban in Afghanistan pledged in a February 2020 agreement with the Trump administration that they would no longer allow al-Qaida or other extremist groups to employ Afghan territory to threaten the United States. However that deal may be imperiled by Biden’s resolution no longer to complete the withdrawal of forces by May 1, as the Trump administration had promised.

The larger danger, Biddle said in an email exchange, is that the withdrawal may perhaps lead to the collapse of Afghan safety forces and multi-sided civil warfare arresting Taliban factions and others “in a extra-lethal model of the civil war of the 1990s.”

“This may be a humanitarian disaster for Afghans — far worse than today’s insurgency,” he said.

More broadly, the absence of U.S. forces in Afghanistan may perhaps lead to additional instability in a scrape with two rival nuclear powers — Pakistan and India, which have insurgencies of their have to deal with.

“Right here’s already a dangerous part of the world; making it worse by allowing the collapse of the Afghan executive is the most fascinating risk right here,” Biddle said.

At a previously pivotal 2nd in the war, Obama took a similar glimpse. When he announced a surge of 30,000 U.S. troops to Afghanistan in December 2009, he argued against attempting to contain extremist threats in the Afghanistan-Pakistan scrape only with what the U.S. military calls “over-the-horizon” forces — troops and aircraft positioned past Afghan borders.

“To abandon this area now — and to rely only on efforts against al-Qaida from a distance — would significantly hamper our ability to maintain the rigidity on al-Qaida and create an unacceptable risk of additional attacks on our homeland and our allies,” Obama said.

So Obama went ahead with a troop buildup aimed at hitting the Taliban so hard that they would agree to negotiate a peace deal. It didn’t work. The Taliban saved battling. Even after President Donald Trump authorized a extra muscular military approach to the Taliban in 2017, the hard-hit militant neighborhood did not quit. It agreed to negotiate with the Afghan executive, nonetheless these talks have stalled.

It’s complicated to assume what has been gained in the 12 years since Obama escalated the war. Afghan safety forces doubtless are stronger, although their resilience will be tested in the absence of U.S. make stronger they grew to depend on. The Afghan executive has no longer strengthened its authority across the nation, and the Pentagon argues that its intense deal with countering insurgents there and in the Heart East has been such a drain on sources that the U.S. is shedding ground against China and Russia.

The war has charge extra than 2,300 U.S. lives and immeasurable suffering among Afghans because the United States invaded in October 2001. Ten years into the war, in May 2011, U.S. forces killed bin Laden in Pakistan, and for a short time it appeared imaginable that Washington would appreciate an opening for ending the war.

A few weeks after bin Laden’s death, a young American soldier at a dusty outpost in eastern Afghanistan asked visiting Defense Secretary Robert Gates what attain the al-Qaida leader’s demise would have on the war, suggesting hope that it may perhaps hasten its halt and allow troops to head residence.

“It’s far too early to order,” Gates answered.

Ten years later, Biden has made up our minds the time has arrive, although for Afghans the war may be far from over.


EDITOR’S NOTE — Robert Burns has reported on the war in Afghanistan because the 2001 U.S. invasion and has coated national safety problems from Washington since 1990.


Associated Press author Eric Tucker contributed to this epic.

Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may no longer be printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed with out permission.

Analysis: Biden takes a risk pulling troops from Afghanistan