Home Canada Canadian Forces pilots not warned about autopilot before deadly Cyclone crash in...

Canadian Forces pilots not warned about autopilot before deadly Cyclone crash in 2020

Canadian Forces pilots not warned about autopilot before deadly Cyclone crash in 2020

As a pilot guided certainly one of Canada’s navy helicopters up into a factual flip, neither his training nor cockpit indicators warned of how a constructed-in autopilot would favor modify and drop the Cyclone into the Ionian Sea, a militia document has concluded.

All six Canadian Forces individuals on board died in the crash on April 29, 2020.

Early Newspaper

According to a board of inquiry document obtained by The Canadian Press, when the pilot modified into once flying the flip, continually known as a “return to target,” he had pointed the nostril up and long-established his toes to flip the helicopter’s tail, overriding the autopilot to entire the manoeuvre of not up to 20 seconds.

The document, nonetheless, stated testing wasn’t finished during the airplane’s certification to name what would happen if a pilot overrode the autopilot extra than “momentarily” and in certain complex scenarios. “The automation principles and philosophy that governed the Cyclone’s create never intended for the (autopilot) to be overridden for extended courses of time, and therefore this modified into once never tested,” it stated.

This modified into once the case even supposing — because the document stated — pilots are known once in some time to override the autopilot system with out manually pressing a button on their modify stick, known as the cyclic.

The document stated that on the time of the crash, the autopilot — referred to because the flight director — modified into once location to an air wobble of about 260 kilometres per hour before certainly one of many pilots pitched the airplane’s nostril upward for the flip.

It modified into once imagined to hover back over HMCS Fredericton and practise hoisting folks onto the deck. Instead, the frigate’s CH-148 Cyclone helicopter crashed off the poke with the circulation of Greece while returning from a NATO training mission. That crash led to the worst single-day loss of life for the Canadian Armed Forces since six troopers had been killed in a roadside bombing in Afghanistan on July 4, 2007.

The document indicated the crash might maybe maybe were averted if the pilot had manually chosen to flip off the autopilot during the flip. However it certainly also stated that it wasn’t ordinary for pilots to override the autopilot and there were no express instructions in the manuals on the necessity to manually flip off the flight director.

In addition, the document stated the pilot looked unaware the laptop would are attempting to regain modify attain the finish of the flip.

When the helicopter flipped around, the document stated, the pilot pulled back as far as he might maybe maybe maybe on the cyclic, attempting to merely the airplane that the laptop modified into once flying into the sea. Within seconds, the helicopter hit the ocean at huge power.

The board of inquiry stated it discovered no evidence the flying pilot identified he had lost modify of the airplane till it modified into once too tedious.

Excessive to the crash, the document stated, modified into once the airplane’s utility, which modified into once certified by the militia. If the autopilot is overridden, the laptop accumulates digital instructions, known as “direct bias accumulation.” The extra instructions a pilot sends manually to the laptop while the airplane is coupled with the autopilot, the extra this bias accumulation occurs, the document stated.


After a pilot overrides the air wobble location by the autopilot, a “feed forward inspect” occurs, the document stated, adding that in some scenarios, “the pilot’s ability to manipulate the airplane shall be diminished or lost.”

The board of inquiry stated the pilots’ training didn’t quilt “with enough detail” certain dangers of flying the airplane, leaving the flyers unaware the autopilot would inspect to maintain modify of the helicopter.

The return-to-target manoeuvre, which led to the crash, modified into once being flown by others in the maritime helicopter community, the document stated. That manoeuvre has been disallowed since the crash.

The document makes six suggestions, five of which involve higher training for pilots to acquire them awake of the skill complications that can maybe maybe happen if they override the autopilot. It instantaneous creating particular cockpit signals pilots might maybe maybe maybe train to warn every other about overriding flight administrators for extended courses of time.

The document also instantaneous the militia like in mind an engineering swap “to robotically disengage the flight director below certain conditions, equivalent to when the flight director is overridden in extra than one axes, or for a protracted duration of time.”

According to a senior militia offer, that advice is not shared in a second, independent document by the militia’s Directorate of Flight Security, anticipated to be launched subsequent week.

The second document stated pilots must be effectively trained to almost instantly press a single button on their modify persist with disengage the autopilot if they’re not getting the response they desire out of their controls. It stated, nonetheless, that robotically disengaging the autopilot might maybe maybe maybe pose its hang dangers in some scenarios, notably when a pilot believes the autopilot will retain functioning.

The second document instead argued that the utility — and its “bias accumulation” — desires to be addressed by American aviation firm Sikorsky Aircraft, the producer of the Cyclone.

RCAF CH-148 Cyclone helicopter

“We like to inspect at that utility and search for if we can eliminate this from the utility altogether, being cautious to treasure in case you acquire any adjustments admire that you simply would possibly maybe maybe maybe introduce a butterfly cease and location off complications in different locations,” the provision stated.

The board of inquiry document, signed by three individuals of the panel on Nov. 20, 2020, concluded the pilots had been not distracted and the crew “flew effectively together.” It added that the airplane captain had a solid direct of the helicopter and the co-pilot confirmed “factual situational awareness” in the route of the mission.

The second document is anticipated to blueprint further analysis on the factors behind the crash.

The militia offer stated the suggestions of the 2 reports must be meshed into a single location of findings for consideration by senior Royal Canadian Air Power officers.

A spokeswoman for Sikorsky referred all questions about the document to the Canadian Forces.

This document by The Canadian Press modified into once first revealed June 25, 2021.

Canadian Forces pilots not warned about autopilot before deadly Cyclone crash in 2020