Home Australia Cruel mutilation of sharks and rays sparks calls for more humane treatment

Cruel mutilation of sharks and rays sparks calls for more humane treatment

Cruel mutilation of sharks and rays sparks calls for more humane treatment

Sharks and stingrays caught off South Australian jetties are being mutilated and thrown abet into the water alive, fishers and scuba divers disclose, prompting calls for more humane treatment of the animals.

Key capabilities:

  • The seabed beneath SA jetties often contains the mutilated carcasses of sharks and rays
  • Some fishers are chopping off tails and fins before throwing the animals abet into the water alive
  • The actions maintain sparked calls for more humane treatment of rays and sharks

The calls diagram after a one-metre-long southern eagle ray used to be left in part filleted on Brighton Shoreline final week, sparking criticism from some people of the community.

Early Newspaper

Chemical engineer and divemaster Daniel Kinasz, who dives at jetties all the simplest arrangement by arrangement of the pronounce, said he had witnessed sharks and rays being mutilated, killed and dumped infinite cases.

WARNING: This article contains photos that some readers may perchance perhaps perhaps also bag distressing. 

Among distressing sights he said he had viewed were sharks and rays having their fins or tails slash off before being thrown abet into the water alive, hooks and long lengths of line being left in an animal’s mouth, unwanted fish being left to suffocate and rot on jetties, and a female enormous white shark being slash up and thrown into the water.

“You even look oldsters benefit their kids to actively shatter them.

“It is no longer unfamiliar to hear any person disclose, ‘Crop the tail off for Steve’.”

Right here’s a reference to the gradual tv personality Steve Irwin, who used to be killed by a stingray’s barb that punctured his coronary heart true by arrangement of the filming of a documentary in 2006.


‘Defenceless’ animals

As a divemaster, Mr Kinasz on a unparalleled basis takes visiting photographers and cinematographers, reminiscent of famed IMAX director Jonathan Chicken, to dive web sites below SA jetties to pass attempting the spectacular surroundings.

But he says the seabed is often littered with the carcasses of dumped animals.

“I’m exhibiting global company around who maintain choice to pass attempting at what now we maintain, and they’re coming from in each build the field to a pickle where, yeah, now we maintain a convention that accepts the abolish of these defenceless animals,” he said.

A scuba diver swims beneath pylons covered in coral.

Diver Daniel Kinasz says some of SA’s most attention-grabbing dive web sites are beneath jetties, nonetheless the seabed is often strewn with the carcasses of mutilated sharks and rays.(

Photo: Uli Kunz


“I also assume we ought to be preserving them barely more and reconsidering what species are centered.”

The most straightforward shark that has security in SA waters is the enormous white and the pronounce’s stingrays are no longer protected at all.

A dead stingray with its tail and wings cut off.

Daniel Kinasz says mutilated ray carcasses are on a unparalleled basis stumbled on beneath SA jetties.  (

Equipped: Daniel Kinasz


To be killed quickly and ‘humanely’  

A spokesperson for the Division of Predominant Industries and Areas said there were about 65 varied species of rays and sharks in SA, with the Port Jackson, gummy, college and bronze whaler sharks essentially the most repeatedly caught, along with southern fiddler and southern eagle rays.

“Leisure fishing for sharks and rays from a ship, jetty or shore is a new exercise in South Australia, with most of the fisheries adopting lift and release practices,” he said.

The code outlines a need for the “respectful and ethical treatment of animals, including fish destined for release or consumption”.

It stipulates that animals that are to be retained ought to be killed straight on landing with a “agency blow to the head”, or by “pithing its brain with a interesting implement”.

Port Jackson shark

Port Jackson sharks are amongst those on a unparalleled basis caught from SA shores.(

ABC News: Jake Sturmer


Fisher criticised for stingray treatment

The honour given to the boring eagle ray at Brighton final week has prompted a young fisher to reveal responsibility for it on a social media online page dedicated to shark and ray fishers.

He said that whereas some fishers release them, he wished to envision out difficult his “first ray” and, after chopping off its tail, killing and filleting it, he dragged it out into waist-high water adjoining to the jetty.

There used to be no advice he treated the ray inhumanely, nonetheless the fisher used to be robustly criticised by others on the online page, who said he ought to maintain harvested more of the eagle ray and disposed of the carcass successfully.

A stingray with a knife hole in its head lays decomposing on the ground

A filleted stingray left at Brighton Shoreline sparked condemnation by fishers and the elevated community.(

Equipped: Rick


“What that man did used to be unsuitable, as some distance as I’m concerned,” a fisher referred to as Matt said.

A ‘strict’ code amongst fishers

Matt said there were quite a bit of “bogans” available in the market with varied opinions, nonetheless fishers from his community were “strict” about how they caught and treated animals to keep some distance from each “pointless struggling”, and losing food.

“You consume your entire lot and you dispose of it properly,” Matt said.

“You build no longer just lunge away it on the seaside for of us to pass attempting it.

He added that shark fishing from seashores ought to be banned because of this of some fishers were “chumming up the water barely to salvage them to diagram in”.

“The majority of the of us are wonderful and there’s a true strictness to attain the lawful ingredient, because of this of we build no longer prefer to lose our privilege,” Matt said.

A hand underwater holds a large hook and tackle

Stout hooks broken-down for shark fishing recovered from the seabed where they’ll hurt animals.(

Equipped: Daniel Kinasz


Recommendation on handling

PIRSA offers guidelines on handling sharks and rays for release, recommending that they’re freed straight and preferably with out being eliminated from the water.

The guidlines disclose a soft, knotless salvage ought to be broken-down for landing if the ray or shark is puny, and they ought to no longer be placed on a warm or dry surface.

Lines ought to be slash from as discontinuance to the hook as which that you may perchance perhaps trust, care ought to be taken no longer to squeeze a shark’s gills, and a soft moist fabric ought to be placed over the animal’s eyes to lend a hand abet it peaceable.

“As soon as landed, resuscitate the animal by working water all the simplest arrangement by arrangement of the gills,” PIRSA’s web space reads.

It will be performed with buckets of seawater, nonetheless also by transferring the animal slowly forwards in the water.

PIRSA warned of us to abet their hands in the abet of the line of a shark’s pectoral fins to slash the prospect of being bitten, and no longer to the touch the tail of a ray, or stand interior its radius, to keep some distance from being struck and stung by its venomous barb.

Cruel mutilation of sharks and rays sparks calls for more humane treatment