Home Breaking News Karen Garner case: Ex-officers face charges in arrest of 73-year-frail Colorado woman...

Karen Garner case: Ex-officers face charges in arrest of 73-year-frail Colorado woman with dementia

Karen Garner case: Ex-officers face charges in arrest of 73-year-frail Colorado woman with dementia


Bodycam photos confirmed Karen Garner’s arrest. Video taken inside the department confirmed officers talking about their exhaust of force.

Early Newspaper

Castle Collins Coloradoan

FORT COLLINS, Colo. — Two former police officers face criminal charges for the way they dealt with the June 2020 arrest of a 73-year-frail Colorado woman with dementia, prosecutors stated Wednesday. 

Former officers Austin Hopp and Daria Jalali every face three charges connected to the arrest of Loveland, Colorado, resident Karen Garner, District Legal professional Gordon McLaughlin announced during an afternoon information convention. 

“It is my ethical accountability to put collectively the facts as they exist to the law because it is written,” McLaughlin stated. “Our regarded as decision in this case nowadays is that criminal charges ought to and were filed against two former Loveland police officers.”

Hopp is facing charges of 2nd-level assault, attempting to influence a public servant and official misconduct in last year’s arrest of Karen Garner in Loveland, a metropolis about 50 miles (80 kilometers) north of Denver. Daria Jalali, who arrived after Garner used to be handcuffed, is facing charges of failing to story exhaust of force, failing to intervene and official misconduct.

“While peace officers are permitted to make exhaust of cheap force to assemble an arrest, the investigation in this case confirmed that Austin Hopp frail excessive force in the arrest of Ms. Garner, and that resulted in serious bodily injury,” McLaughlin stated. 

Associated: Loveland council votes to approve Community Belief Commission in response to Garner arrest

Hopp also made “gigantic omissions” in his story of the arrest “in an are attempting to thwart the investigation of his behavior,” McLaughlin stated.

McLaughlin stated the investigation confirmed Jalali witnessed the excessive force and “failed to are living up to her tasks below the law and as a sworn peace officer to either intervene or story … that behavior.” 

“I fully enhance these charges,” Loveland Police Chief Robert Ticer stated in a separate information convention Wednesday afternoon. Ticer stated the “charges stand for themselves” and “the actions and attitudes” of the former officers “are in relate contrast to the tradition we are attempting to create.”

“We note the will for accountability and justice and we are seeing that nowadays for Ms. Garner with the charges being filed,” Ticer stated.

Ticer stated he used to be “no longer taken aback by the charges,” and his reaction to those charges is “vulgar disappointment as a neighborhood, as a police department and as a human being.”

Ticer stated a third-social gathering investigation overseen by the metropolis of Loveland’s human resources department will begin instantly and that his department will cooperate with the criminal investigation.

Ticer cited three actions he stated the department has taken since the lawsuit used to be filed:

“A majority of our police officers” have taken Alzheimer’s awareness training and, starting subsequent month, the department will put further de-escalation training in lisp, he stated.

Dealing with dementia: First responders must ‘unhurried down,’ interrogate questions, neighborhood says

An assistant metropolis attorney is assisting in a analysis of all exhaust of force instances, starting with instances in 2019 and with any future exhaust of force instances, he added.

“This further layer of scrutiny is famous no longer most real looking possible to the department, however to the neighborhood, the neighborhood that we support, to be certain that the policies and guidelines are being followed.”

Ticer stated this incident does no longer replicate an overarching challenge within the police department’s tradition. 

“Our officers that work here appropriate now are integrity based mostly, they’ve ethics, they’ve accountability, they work so demanding,” he stated. “… They win it the correct manner, the officers that are employed here nowadays.”

Garner’s attorney, Sarah Schielke, stated the charges against Hopp and Jalali “a begin, however it is a ways no longer staunch ample.


A prosecutor says two police officers involved in the arrest of a 73-year-frail Colorado woman with dementia were charged. The woman’s family says they are contented for the charges, however more individuals needs to be held to blame. (Might also fair 19)

AP Domestic

“Develop no mistake, the Garner family feels astronomical reduction the DA’s office has charged some of these criminals with staunch crimes.”

Schielke stated she believed charges will must were filed against the opposite officers named in the federal lawsuit.

“In a roundabout way, the DA office’s decision to discontinue their charging decisions after Hopp and Jalali has left this family with more questions than solutions and more fret than reduction,” Schielke stated.

This incident did not happen in a vacuum, Schielke stated, or the opposite officers who witnessed and heard concerning the arrest would have stepped in to create Garner with the medic

Garner’s daughter, Allisa Swartz, offered an change on her mother: “She’s staunch definitely insecure and traumatized,” Swartz stated. “Instead of embracing us because we are her cherished ones, she pushes us away. She’s staunch insecure.”

How the investigation labored

The charges against Hopp and Jalali were filed as a result of a Serious Incident Response Crew investigation launched by McLaughlin on April 19 and led by Castle Collins Police Products and companies.

CIRT investigations usually involve a combination of officers from pretty just a few businesses, however because officers from Loveland police and the Larimer County Sheriff’s Office had contact with Garner during her arrest, it used to be determined that most real looking possible Castle Collins police would behavior the investigation. 

“Belief is key in the criminal justice system,” Castle Collins Police Chief Jeff Swoboda stated during the district attorney’s information convention. “And CIRT framework is intended to standardize investigations where they lisp a top class on accountability and transparency.”

Three Castle Collins police detectives were assigned rotund time to this case, Swoboda stated, and “left no stone unturned.”

During the monthlong investigation, they performed 24 interviews, reviewed and transcribed hours of video and audio recordings, and presented their final with regards to 700-page CIRT investigation story to McLaughlin on Monday, Swoboda stated. 

Be taught about: Loveland Police Department, Karen Garner family focus on investigation

“Ensuring public believe in law enforcement and the criminal justice system is key to our neighborhood security and our classic perception in equity,” McLaughlin stated. 

McLaughlin stated the “thorough investigation” performed by Castle Collins police “will allow us to whisk forward in the pursuit of justice in this case for Karen Garner, for her family and for the Larimer County neighborhood.” 

“I imagine this decision speaks clearly to our neighborhood that accountability will be completed by way of our independent Serious Incident Response Crew route of, and I’m hoping nowadays will be a step in building believe between the criminal justice neighborhood and the Larimer County neighborhood,” McLaughlin stated.

Why other officers are no longer facing criminal charges

Hopp and Jalali weren’t the most real looking possible officers involved in the incident. They, alongside with former neighborhood carrier officer Tyler Blackett, resigned from the department last month.

The three former officers and two officers aloof with the department — Sgt. Philip Metzler and Sgt. Antolina Hill — are named in a federal lawsuit filed April 14 by Garner’s family alleging excessive exhaust of force and other civil rights violations. 

Metzler, Hill, and Blackett weren’t charged as a result of the CIRT investigation.

Metzler has been positioned on paid administrative leave, per department policy. Hill is aloof working her fashioned tasks, Ticer stated on the April 30 information convention.

McLaughlin stated the investigation regarded at your total officers involved in this case, and whereas he stated there used to be evidence of concerning behavior, no other officers’ behavior rose to the level of criminal charges.

Public outcry: Residents march on Loveland Police Department demanding justice for Karen Garner

Garner used to be forcibly arrested whereas walking residence from Walmart, where workers instructed police that she attempted to whisk away without paying for roughly $14 worth of devices, according to the lawsuit.

During the arrest, officers dislocated Garner’s shoulder, fractured her arm, and sprained her wrist, according to the lawsuit.

‘I won’t stand for somebody looking the opposite direction’

McLaughlin stated he first modified into mindful of this incident when the federal lawsuit used to be filed mid-April. When he considered the publicly released videos in this case, he stated he used to be “instantly concerned with what I saw.”

McLaughlin took office as district attorney on Jan. 12 and used to be no longer half of the district attorney’s office when Garner used to be arrested in June and when the office dropped the charges against her in August. 

McLaughlin stated someone in the district attorney’s office on the time did perceive some video in the case sooner than deciding to disregard charges against Garner and that individual remains employed by the district attorney’s office. 

“I have made it very definite to all americans in my office, attorneys and otherwise that I won’t stand for somebody looking the opposite direction on evidence corresponding to that,” McLaughlin stated. “What the expectations were last year weren’t my decision.”

Discover Sady Swanson on Twitter @sadyswan

Contributing: The Associated Press.


Repeat Thumbnails

Repeat Captions

Read or Share this legend: https://www.usatoday.com/legend/information/nation/2021/05/19/karen-garner-arrest-loveland-colorado-police-officers-charges/5178022001/

Find Recent & Worn Automobiles


Powered by Automobiles.com

Karen Garner case: Ex-officers face charges in arrest of 73-year-frail Colorado woman with dementia