Home Australia ‘Not stunning, not green, not even wholesome’: Author slams salmon farming

‘Not stunning, not green, not even wholesome’: Author slams salmon farming

‘Not stunning, not green, not even wholesome’: Author slams salmon farming

Booker prize-winning creator Richard Flanagan has taken a swipe at Tasmania’s salmon industry, describing it as “one tall lie”.

Key facets:

  • Richard Flanagan mentioned he used to be compelled to jot down after witnessing the degradation of his local atmosphere
  • He alleges up to “a third of salmon” is “processed industrial rooster … feathers, elephantine and the macerated beaks, claws, guts”
  • He mentioned the “industry” is “very apt at silencing its critics”

Flanagan took goal at what he described the industry’s “harsh” animal administration practices and the authorities law — claiming the product being equipped is not as wholesome as advertised and warned of what a mass enlargement of the industry would impart. 

Early Newspaper

Speaking on the ABC’s AM program, Flanagan mentioned he’d been motivated to jot down his recent e book, Toxic: The Rotting Underbelly of the Tasmanian Salmon Alternate, as a result of the “leisurely destruction” of the atmosphere advance his Bruny Island shack from where he had written all of his old books.

“The spur used to be that the water started loss of life, the fish started vanishing, slime and algae started acting,” Flanagan mentioned.

Richard Flanagan looks at the camera.

Tasmanian creator Richard Flanagan.(

ABC News: James Dunlevie


“I realised that Tasmanian Atlantic salmon is shapely one tall lie. It be not stunning, or not it is not green and or not it is not even wholesome.”

Mr Flanagan, who acknowledged that there used to be “another big sea preserve coming that the exclaim authorities is maintaining restful” mentioned his e book used to be not timed to coincide with the exclaim election advertising campaign, which is going down a three hundred and sixty five days sooner than scheduled.

“It be got nothing to total with the Tasmanian election, but it completely does develop very serious components.

Farmed salmon in an aquaculture project off Tasmania

Opponents to farmed salmon indicate environmental components.

Flanagan mentioned the planned enlargement of the industry incorporated areas like Boat Harbour and Stanley on the north west flit, Port Arthur in the south.

He brushed off the industry’s inform of sustainable farming practices and mentioned when customers use salmon they had been also ingesting rooster “feathers, elephantine and the macerated beaks, claws [and] guts”.

Flanagan mentioned a salmon processor he had spoken to had wired that the ranges of ethoxyquin — a stabiliser used in salmon feed — in Tasmanian salmon had been effectively inner the European limits of 150 milligrams per kilogram of feed.

“However what if there are not any safe ranges and why is this being kept so secret?” he mentioned.

Flanagan also mentioned fish meal used to be getting used much less by the industry, and replaced by plant-primarily based completely and animal product: “Processed industrial rooster.”

Flanagan mentioned he wanted to “see this industry continue to exist” but added he believed it to be a “very little employer in Tasmania” with spherical “1,500 jobs”.

“They [producers] would possibly maybe likely beget to be going to land-primarily based completely, that’s what’s going down spherical the enviornment.

“However advance down right here and test with the commercial fisherman, the recreational fisherman, to the shack proprietor, to the kayaker, to the surfer and ask them what goes on on.”

A fish pen

A salmon farming enclosure in the initiating water off the Tasmanian flit.(

Supplied: Huon Aquaculture


Flanagan claims there will likely be a gigantic enlargement of salmon pens in the exclaim that Tasmanian authorities had not suggested voters about.

“I do know from sources inner authorities that what’s being proposed are cherished areas of the north west flit … from Burnie thru to west of Wynyard. These are comely locations like Boat Harbour, likely Rocky Cape, likely Desk Cape.” 

“It is probably going you will most likely hear all this nonsense about world’s most intriguing apply … about how we are living inner rules, there are rather a couple of rules, none of which are enforced,” he mentioned.

Salmon farming

There are three significant producers of farmed salmon in Tasmania.(

ABC News: Sophie Zoellner


Deputy Liberal Jeremy Rockliff leader did not rule out a gigantic enlargement of fish farms in the exclaim but mentioned the community would be consulted sooner than any plans stepped forward.

“There’ll be no enlargement of any salmon industry across Tasmanian waters with out thorough diagnosis, thorough session,” he mentioned.

“There would possibly maybe be very a couple of work to total in phrases of building alternatives for aquaculture, guaranteeing the sustainability of aquaculture.”

Mr Rockliff mentioned there had been “big beneficial properties” in the transparency, sustainability and law of the salmon industry for the explanation that Liberals came to energy in 2014. 

Native industry a ‘global leader’, spokesperson says

A Tasmanian Salmonid Growers Affiliation (TSGA) spokesperson mentioned the organisation used to be “restful reading the e book with a science-primarily based completely lens”.

“Richard Flanagan is primarily renowned for his works of fiction. The TSGA urges folks to be suggested by facts, widely accessible from governments and main researchers, and from the reporting of the corporations,” the spokesperson mentioned.

“Moral knowledge about our industry is equipped from science-primarily based completely organisations like CSIRO and Institute for Marine and Antarctic Stories and other universities spherical the enviornment.”

“Tasmanian salmon is a global leader, independently accredited by organisations just like the Aquaculture Stewardship Council, Handiest Aquaculture Practices and the RSPCA.”

“The TSGA welcomes sturdy discussion — our industry is continuously striving to total better for the atmosphere and our communities, and suggestions is a a truly great half of that — but debate must preserve in all facets and preserve into consideration science-primarily based completely evidence.” 

‘Not stunning, not green, not even wholesome’: Author slams salmon farming