Home Australia There’s ‘no law against manipulation’ in $2b water markets, but ACCC pushes...

There’s ‘no law against manipulation’ in $2b water markets, but ACCC pushes for change

There’s ‘no law against manipulation’ in $2b water markets, but ACCC pushes for change

Australia’s $2 billion water market wants a predominant overhaul, according to the Australian Competition and Client Charge.

Key points:

  • The ACCC has made 29 recommendations to overhaul the water market
  • It recommends a brand recent, dedicated regulator
  • The Water Minister can also merely no longer decide to a timeline for implementation

An 18-month look by the competition watchdog found it used to be no longer unlawful to manipulate the Murray-Darling Basin’s water markets, but rapid water affords be subjected to bigger scrutiny and transparency.

Early Newspaper

The ACCC acknowledged the market had evolved as a derivative of a protracted time of reform geared toward recovering water from the atmosphere and used to be now in determined want of its personal dedicated region of reforms.

It found an absence of attention by federal and say governments had ended in in type mistrust in the market and a perception that it used to be rife with manipulation and corruption.

The inflame and suspicion boiled over during the scorching drought, prompting High Minister Scott Morrison to determine to the ACCC inquiry sooner than the 2019 federal election.

“It is miles no longer surprising that the requirements of a successfully-functioning market bear no longer been entrance and centre [over the last two decades],” ACCC deputy chair Mick Keogh acknowledged upon the initiate of the 700-web grunt legend.

“So what we’re saying is that whereas you happen to want individuals to be confident in the market, to invest accurately, to maximise water efficiency, then you definitely genuinely want individuals confident in the equity of the market, and that will require some work.”

A tree bends its boughs over a river shining like glass at dusk.

The legend found no proof of corruption, contrary to in type perception.(

ABC Mildura Swan Hill: Alexandra Treloar


Now not fit for reason

At the center of the ACCC’s 29 recommendations used to be the establishment of a brand recent “Water Markets Agency”, which would possibly well just in a identical – although scaled relief – formula to the Australian Energy Market.

Thru Basin-broad legislation, the recent agency would bear the energy to oversee and withhold an eye in the marketplace, in addition to the merchants, brokers and other intermediaries that operate in it.

It would impose a well-known code of conduct for brokers and intermediaries — at the 2d simplest a voluntary code exists.

“It would be a single source of truth, so the overall information on water trades would be reported to the agency,” Mr Keogh acknowledged.

In addition, the legend acknowledged, the quality of that information would be improved to “enable trades to be traced and merchants to be identified in the course of areas and a pair of accounts”.

ACCC Deputy Chair Mick Keogh at a microphone stand.

Mick Keogh says recent and dedicated legislation is desired to beef up the procedure water markets work.(

ABC Mildura-Swan Hill: Christopher Testa


Dismal water

The ACCC legend used to be deeply crucial concerning the say of information availability in the course of the water market.

It found that information on water prices and trades used to be at the 2d spread in the course of a pair of Basin say registers and the Bureau of Meteorology.

The complexity made it on the area of very unlikely for irrigators to perform confident choices about when to win or sell water.

“We analysed eight million transactions between 2012 and 2019 and we found them incredibly no longer easy to string collectively in a procedure that gave you a clear image of what used to be happening in the market,” Mr Keogh acknowledged.

“Forty per cent of them didn’t bear a tag linked to them, a kind of them assign no longer desire a date linked to them, and lots of befell in the course of a pair of jurisdictions.”

Attempts made between 2010 and 2014 to house the project and harmonise the sequence of information failed, but the ACCC believed there bear been a resolution of low tag applied sciences accessible that can even to fix the project.

“I cite the instance of the single-contact payroll system, the save businesses can employ a range of accounting utility systems that can per chance well each and each legend the specified information to the Australian Tax Space of job,” Mr Keogh acknowledged.

“We look a identical mannequin applying here, the save the overall existing registers and irrigation infrastructure operators would continue as they are now, and the best additional requirement would be to on an ordinary foundation legend that information to a central repository.”

The legend also recommends say governments work collectively the foundations and processes they employ to whine water allocations for irrigators.

A large dam with the sun low in the sky behind it.

The legend recommends say governments overhaul the procedure they keep in touch and how water allocations are made.(

ABC Rural: Clint Jasper


‘No law against manipulation’

Mr Keogh acknowledged it used to be untenable for the market to continue without major reform.

“This is capable of per chance well ethical assassinate the boldness of the contributors and the overall advantages that it brings might well be instant eroded,” he acknowledged.

The shortage of obvious, digestible market information led many to suspect that mammoth company agribusinesses and non-farming investors bear been manipulating the market during the drought.

The ACCC found that in 2018-19, “institutional investors” accounted for about 11 per cent of the water allocations purchased and 21 per cent of the allocations sold.

A single mammoth investor used to be a truly unparalleled dealer of water in that duration.

But in the ruin the ACCC found no proof of market manipulation and acknowledged mammoth movements in tag bear been no longer the consequence of dealer misconduct.

“There’s no longer always any law against market manipulation in the Murray-Darling Basin water markets,” Mr Keogh acknowledged.

Keith Pitt looks to the Opposition benches while sitting in the House of Representatives

Keith Pitt will raise the legend’s recommendations to the Basin states.(

ABC Information: Matt Roberts


Road to reform

Water Minister Keith Pitt wouldn’t decide to a timeline for implementing the ACCC’s reforms.

But he acknowledged the authorities used to be concious that Basin communities bear been “exhausted” by the unhurried pace of reform.

Constitutional accountability for water management rests with say governments and implementing 90 per cent of the recommendations would require them to cooperate with the federal authorities.

“The legend took two years to finish,” Mr Pitt acknowledged.

There’s ‘no law against manipulation’ in $2b water markets, but ACCC pushes for change