Home Canada What to expect from the Meng Wanzhou extradition ruling

What to expect from the Meng Wanzhou extradition ruling

What to expect from the Meng Wanzhou extradition ruling

Meng Wanzhou left the B.C. Supreme Courtroom in Vancouver closing week for what might be one amongst the final times.

Early Newspaper

The Huawei government’s high-profile extradition hearing sooner or later wrapped up Wednesday, nearly three years since her arrest rocked Canada-China relatives. Within days of her detention, Beijing arrested two Canadians, Michael Spavor and Michael Kovrig, and sentenced another, Robert Schellenberg, to death.

Click to play video: 'Canada’s relationship with China takes another major hit after sentencing of Michael Spavor'

Canada’s relationship with China takes another major hit after sentencing of Michael Spavor

Canada’s relationship with China takes another major hit after sentencing of Michael Spavor – Aug 11, 2021

As Meng’s committal hearings started earlier this month, a Chinese court announced that it had convicted Spavor of espionage and sentenced him to 11 years of reformatory, whereas also upholding Schellenberg’s death sentence (the Chinese government quiet formally denies the cases are linked).

Story continues beneath advertisement

Their fates, in addition to Meng’s, might maybe per chance now rest in the hands of B.C. Supreme Courtroom Affiliate Chief Justice Heather Holmes.

“The Chinese government has been constructive: If Mrs. Meng is no longer returned to China, there will likely be no growth,” acknowledged Guy Saint-Jacques, Canada’s mature ambassador to China.

Media and security out of doors Meng Wanzhou’s Vancouver dwelling on Also can 27, 2020.

Corey Callahan / World News

The 49-yr-aged chief monetary officer at the Chinese telecom giant used to be arrested in December 2018 at the demand of the United States. Meng is accused of environment up deceptive statements about Huawei’s exchange dealings in Iran all over a 2013 presentation to HSBC in Hong Kong, which allegedly save aside the British bank in risk of violating U.S. sanctions.

Meng’s lawyers argued she never misled the bank and the fraud costs are purely political.

“Meng Wanzhou is a political pawn,” acknowledged Alykhan Velshi, Huawei Canada’s Vice President of Corporate Affairs. “She’s been caught in the heart of this U.S.-China exchange fight. This case is set exchange, it’s about geopolitics, it’s about leverage, but it’s no longer about justice.”

Story continues beneath advertisement

Huawei Canada says it is miles an injured bystander of the Trump administration’s exchange struggle with China and stays hopeful that it is miles might maybe quiet be ready to promote next-skills cyber web tools to the Trudeau government. Alykhan Velshi, vp of corporate affairs at Huawei Canada, holds a media availability in Ottawa, Monday, July 22, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick.

Velshi pointed to comments made by U.S. President Donald Trump following Meng’s arrest in 2018, when he told the Reuters news agency he would “surely intervene” in the case if he concept it could per chance maybe per chance wait on right a favourable exchange deal with China.

“The Trump administration primarily conjured up a victim in HSBC to interpret her detention, so as that she might be weak as leverage in this U.S.-China exchange fight,” Velshi told World News.

Click to play video: 'Lawyers for Huawei executive cast doubts on who knew what, when'

Lawyers for Huawei government forged doubts on who knew what, when

Lawyers for Huawei government forged doubts on who knew what, when – Mar 1, 2021

HSBC suffered no real monetary losses as a outcomes of Meng’s statements, which makes the U.S. extradition demand odd, according to College of Alberta Legislation Professor Joanna Harrington.

Story continues beneath advertisement

“The U.S. has save aside so mighty effort into an allegation of fraud that came about out of doors the United States, no longer by an American and no longer primarily an American victim,” Harrington acknowledged.

“Felony regulation is frequently territorial; That’s where your evidence is, it’s where your witnesses are. It doesn’t imply we are able to’t non-public an extraterritorial criminal case, but this one is odd.”

From time to time all over the extradition hearing, Justice Holmes sounded skeptical of the U.S. costs, at one point asking the prosecution: “Isn’t it odd that one would explore a fraud case without a real be troubled, decades later, and one whereby the alleged victim — a gargantuan institution — looks to non-public rather a lot of other folks internal the institution who had all the facts which are surely acknowledged to non-public been misrepresented?”

B.C criminal expert Gary Botting has tried tons of of extradition cases all over his 30-yr career and acknowledged the teach’s comments are great.

“The questions that she asked and comments that she made seemed to showcase that she’s no longer impressed by the energy of the evidence,” Botting told World News. (Following Meng’s arrest, Botting used to be paid by Huawei to provide a written notion on the case.)

But Botting emphasised that despite the truth that the teach is unimpressed with the evidence, the bar for extradition is low. Authorities lawyers simplest want to point to that there would be sufficient evidence to bring the accused to trial if the crime had been dedicated in Canada.

Story continues beneath advertisement

Between 2008-2018, Canada simplest rejected about one per cent of U.S. extradition requests.

“We’re a patsy for the United States. They declare ‘jump’ and we’re announcing, ‘how high?’” acknowledged Botting, who has long campaigned to toughen Canada’s extradition requirements.

Justice Holmes will spot a date for her ruling on October 21, but the final resolution will then topple to Canada’s justice minister. A crew of high-profile mature Canadian diplomats and mature parliamentarians has called on Ottawa to exchange Meng for the two Michaels.

Top Minister Justin Trudeau has argued that any intervention in the case would undermine Canada’s “autonomous judicial system,” although extraditions are eventually a political resolution below Canadian regulation.

Meng Wanzhou, chief monetary officer of Huawei, returns to B.C. Supreme Courtroom after a destroy from her extradition hearing, in Vancouver, on Wednesday, August 18, 2021.


If Meng loses and the justice minister orders she be extradited, she’s expected to charm, which can per chance maybe per chance explore the case fade on for a whole lot of years.

© 2021 World News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

What to expect from the Meng Wanzhou extradition ruling